Megan McLachlan talks to casting directors Bernard Telsey and Adam Caldwell about going back to their roots to cast Sian Heder’s Being Heumann.
If you’re a casting director looking at the extensive cast in Being Heumann, you have to ask yourself, “Where do you start?”
“You start with Judy,” said Being Heumann casting director Adam Caldwell.
Of course, Caldwell is referring to Judy Heumann, whom the film follows, as she leads a sit-in in San Francisco to protest the delayed passage of Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act, which would provide more accessibility to those with disabilities.
“You read the script, and think, ‘How are you going to do this?'” said casting director Bernard Telsey. “Because you pride yourself as a casting director on being able to answer the crossword puzzle really quickly. Like, Sian, these are the 10 people you should consider for this part. These are the six people for the other part. And this was not going to be one of those things. If anything, it was going to get you back in touch with your early roots as a casting director.”
Finding Ruth Madeley, Being Heumann‘s Breakout
With Judy being such a crucial character, how did the casting directors go about finding their leading lady in Ruth Madeley?
“We had auditioned [Ruth] just a year and a half earlier for the Wicked movie,” said Telsey. “We remember her being someone who stood out. And then of course we knew her BAFTA television thing. So she definitely was someone that everyone was suggesting and knowing, you know, like if you’re talking about working actors in their thirties in wheelchairs, Ruth is on that list.”
Telsey said that was the beauty of this project: that they didn’t know in advance who was the right person until they used the audition and casting process.
“And she kept surprising us,” added Caldwell. “Anytime we would see her. Ultimately it was like four or five times we saw her, including the in-person final callback in New York for two days. And then chemistry reads with Kitties (actresses who auditioned for the part of Kitty).”
Caldwell and Telsey would throw suggestions at her, and Madeley kept hitting the ball.
“We’d kind of like look at each other and be like, ‘Okay, she’s coming through here too,” said Caldwell. “Finding really great stuff every time.”
I had a great conversation with Telsey and Caldwell about their fascinating work on the film, which will be honored with a Gotham Ensemble Tribute at the 36th annual Gotham Film Awards later this month.

![Max Hegewald On His Controversial Gay-Themed Film ‘Free At Heart’ [VIDEO]](https://thecontending.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/FREE_27_klein-75x75.jpg)





