Ever since The Debut premiered at the Telluride Film Festival on September 3rd, the rave reviews have come in high, full-throated volume. I will not be found dissenting, but what I will say is the film’s genuinely radical nature has been greatly undersold. Jesse Eisenberg’s follow-up to his excellent Oscar-winning A Real Pain is so inventive and fearless that it almost makes his last film as a director look conventional. A Real Pain was hardly thus, but The Debut is absolutely unmoored (no pun intended, but thoroughly enjoyed just the same), in a good way. It’s also a film walking such a high wire that, if anyone other than Julianne Moore played the lead, the tenuous balance the film must strike would not hold.
The basic premise of a reserved housewife named Mona (Julianne Moore) finding her inner creative being through a role in a community theater production hardly sounds like a wild affair. But that’s the thing about movies—sometimes you just have to see the damn thing. Eisenberg, who also wrote the film and has a small role, continually ratchets up this comedy, drama, musical, character study, loony tune with seemingly every passing moment. On my way out of the theater, I heard one patron say, “It’s like the Coen Brothers in Hudsucker Proxy mode directing Waiting For Guffman. However overly succinct and too cute by half that remark may read, it’s not exactly wrong, either.
In the early going, The Debut plays like a fairly straight comedy, with a seemingly underqualified Mona driving Jerry, the director of a production of a fictional musical called Nosy Neighbors (Eisenberg wrote the music and lyrics, too, because oh, what the hell, why not?) to his wit’s end. Because Paul Giamatti plays Jerry, every wit-losing second plays out on his character’s face and in his exasperated tone with a seething hilarity. At the same time, Jerry sees himself as something of a genius, despite his modest lot in theater life, so he encourages Mona to let it rip. Little does he know what kind of monster he is about to unleash upon his production.
With each passing scene, Moore’s Mona becomes continually untethered from her former self. What’s so exciting about The Debut is that Mona isn’t just finding her character in the play by letting it rip; she’s finding her true self, and her true self is kind of scary. She’s not wearing a mask or putting up a front; she’s tearing the mask from her face and crumbling the facade. When Jerry creates a role play/acting challenge for Mona: to convince him to hand over rent money to her character in the play (Miss Danielle), he sets Mona’s freak flag ‘a flyin.’ It’s a remarkable sequence where Jerry relentlessly eggs her on to raise the stakes, and Mona becomes increasingly manic, profane, and all but unhinged. Moore is so staggering that I almost forgot to laugh. Why? Because I was in awe.
Through this exercise, Mona is set free. Suddenly, the wallflower becomes a prima donna, questioning every line on the page, giving her character an impromptu “Bahston” accent, and going full method actor to such a degree that it would make Daniel Day-Lewis blush with humiliation. DDL’s “Bill the Butcher” would be no match for Mona the South Jersey mousewife. Moore, still luminous while midway through her seventh decade of life, has long been accepted as one of the great actors of her generation. Her five Oscar nominations (including a Best Actress win for Still Alice) and laundry list of memorable performances attest to her distinction.
What should also be noted is the incredibly high level of difficulty she has so often worked at. Think of the extreme environmental sensitivity of Carol in Safe. Her pornstar who can’t convincingly say her movie-within-a-movie lines in Boogie Nights. Sarah, the atheist who makes a deal with god in The End of the Affair. Linda Partridge, the quaking, frenetic drug addict in Magnolia. The deeply repressed duo of Cathy and Laura from Far From Heaven and The Hours. Charley, the socialite hopelessly in love with a gay man in A Single Man. Her human-like performance (no small feat) as Sarah Palin in Game Change. The title character in Gloria Bell, who experiences a sexual awakening in her fifties. Her Mary Kay Letourneau child-rapist doppelgänger in May December. And now Mona in The Debut. Moore’s range and willingness to take risks is unparalleled.
I swear, while plenty of praise and admiration has been served up to Moore over her distinguished career, she still is underserved. Sure, we all know she’s great, but if we took a beat and thought about just how great she has been, we’d all probably get dizzy from the exercise.
As much as The Debut is a complete auteurist triumph for Eisenberg behind the camera, this film could not afford to have almost any other female actor in the world playing Mona. Maybe two or three women in her field could get within shouting distance of her work here, but I would not take that bet. It’s one for suckers.
Moore, eleven years removed from her last Oscar nomination and currently the odds-on favorite to win a second statue next year, is so good in The Debut that I’m not sure there’s a reason to fill out the category with four other contenders. Mona is not a performance to compete with; it’s one to revere with great haste and affection.
With The Debut, Moore has turned legacy into legend. In playing a character on the verge of a nervous breakdown, she has taken Mona’s frenetic exhilaration and turned it into a nervous breakthrough. She is now on an even higher plane.
The Debut screened at the Virginia Film Festival on October 21, 2026







