Let me start with my least favorite cinematic trivia question:
How many times has John Turturro been nominated for an Oscar?
The answer is zero. It seems impossible, but it’s true. Not for Do the Right Thing. Not for Miller’s Crossing. Not for Barton Fink. Not for Quiz Show. Not for The Big Lebowski. Not for O Brother Where Art Thou? Not for Gloria Bell. Not for The Room Next Door. Not for anything.
The good news is The Only Living Pickpocket in New York may just change that. Turturro stars as Harry, an analog thief in a digital world. He’s a man out of time who is running out of time, especially after lifting the wrong person’s bag.
Harry isn’t a master thief attempting to pull off a big score. He’s a grinder who takes to his light-fingered occupation much the same way a plumber takes to a pipe. He goes out among the people, lifting their wallets and jimmying their locks. He might bump right into you hard enough for you to turn your head, but you’ll never feel your money clip stray from your trousers. Watching Harry “work” in such a masterful fashion, you almost admire him. Harry utilizes misdirection and sleight of hand so skillfully, he’s nothing short of a magician.
Written and directed by Noah Segan, The Only Living Pickpocket in New York may take place in the modern day, but the film’s tone and tenor are straight out of the character-driven cinema of the 1970s. Segan’s film has more in common with Karel Reisz’s The Gambler (starring James Caan), Altman’s gambling drama California Split (with George Segal), or Ulu Grosbard’s character study of a low-level criminal Straight Time (Dustin Hoffman) than it does any modern film you can think of. Filmgoers of a certain age may well find themselves thinking, “This might be what a Robert Altman and Sidney Lumet collaboration might have looked like” while watching this picture. It’s that good, and that particular.
It also helps that Turturro is so utterly winning as Harry. Yes, he’s a criminal who is aging out of contemporary life, but he’s also rational, smart, funny, and easy to warm to. Late in the film, Harry spots another thief making a move on the subway. He lures the younger thief over with his own wallet, stops him just as his pocket is being picked, and then dispenses a lesson in how the fellow might improve his technique. The older man sees the opportunity to improve a wallet rustler’s life on the job, and the younger man is rapt for the lesson.
The Only Living Pickpocket in New York has so many lived-in moments. In fact, all 88 minutes of the film’s concise running time feel effortlessly authentic. This isn’t a film trying too hard. It knows what it’s doing, and you feel that expertise throughout. As low-key as the film presents itself, it’s Alan paradoxically thrilling. Harry’s subculture of fences and marks is a world that is plainly within our vision, yet somehow out of our sight. All we see is surface. Harry sees opportunity in the absentminded commuter, exits as escape routes, and evidence disposal bins at every corner trash can.
And boy, does this movie know New York City. From the Hudson River through the streets of Manhattan and Chinatown to the below-ground trains that take New Yorkers to and fro, Sagan’s film is a series of moving postcards steeped in authenticity and grit. It’s rare to see a film understand its locations so well. Every bodega, subway stop, and street corner is purposeful without drawing attention to itself. It would be wrong, very wrong, to refer to a film this specific as being casual, but the ease with which cinematographer Sam Levy’s camera captures Harry’s environment matches the ease with which Harry commits his crimes. Gary Lionelli’s jazzy score hits all the right notes, too. Every individual part of this film fits into the greater whole.
As good as Harry is at his profession (which is to say, very), the risks of stealing for a living are always evident. Catching Harry in the act might be a feat too mean for most, but modern life’s series of surveillance cameras and traceable devices have added a greater layer of complexity to Harry’s endeavors. Harry is a Luddite when it comes to technology, and there is a cost to not growing your skill set.
When the bill of progress comes due, Harry’s regimented day-to-day life is upended to such a degree that he doesn’t know if he will see the sunset. Arrangements have to be made. Loose ends need tying up. There are farewells to be communicated.
The film’s cast is stacked at every turn. Turturro is supported by Steve Buscemi as a pawnbroker who doesn’t mind trading in stolen goods. Giancarlo Esposito adds grace notes as a sympathetic detective. The rising young actor Will Price impresses as a mark who won’t let Harry off the hook. Tatiana Maslany and Jamie Lee Curtis also deliver superb cameos.
But in the end, the film belongs to Turturro, who is in every scene of this perfectly modulated and immaculately efficient drama about how we behave when we know the clock is running out.
John Turturro is one of the best actors of his generation. I think it’s fair to say that if you dropped him into another generation, that wouldn’t change. This film reminds you of how great he has been, and how great he still is. It’s also one of the best films of the year.
The Only Living Pickpocket in New York screened at the Virgina Film Festival on October 21, 2026







