A documentary in the Best Picture race? What is this, 1995?
With You Can See Everything smashing records, the Best Documentary Feature race has become a hot topic, with many fans hoping the A24 film enters the Best Picture race. However, this talk about a box office doc making it to the big dance isn’t new.
After all, back in 2004, Fahrenheit 9/11 and Super Size Me were huge box office hits, with the former stirring controversy when it became available on television ahead of the presidential election, effectively disqualifying it from Oscar consideration.
But the film I am most concerned with in comparison to YCSE is one from 1994, a documentary that also vied for a Best Picture nomination in addition to a Best Doc nomination—and ended up getting neither. I’m talking about Hoop.
Hoop Dreams Demonstrated a Disconnect Between Critics and the Academy
The success of Hoop Dreams was a bit of a Cinderella story itself. A 171-minute documentary about two high school students’ dreams of becoming professional basketball players became one of the biggest hits of the year, earning $11 million at the box office and making it to the top of both Roger Ebert and Gene Siskel’s year-end lists.
As a surprise hit, soon there was talk of the film making it into the Best Picture race, something championed by many, including Ebert, who called the film “one of the great movie-going experiences of my lifetime.”
But the Academy did not feel the same. While many ranked it highly, apparently, a flashlight system, consisting of voters shining flashlights when they were “done” with a film, revealed that many shut it off within the first 15 minutes. (Because of Hoop Dreams’ snub, Ebert and others would go on to advocate for changes to how documentary voting took place, eliminating that weird flashlight process.)
What Does Hoop Dreams Have to Do with YCSE?
You might be asking what these documentaries have in common. Okay!
Both were box office hits, with approximately the same run times (YCSE is three minutes longer), and have glowing, positive reviews from critics. (Of course, differences include the racial experiences depicted in each film, obviously.)
Even though the documentary voting system has changed since and because of Hoop Dreams, that doesn’t mean documentary voters have all changed. Last year, The Perfect Neighbor, which swept many awards, didn’t win the Oscar, with many saying doc voters ultimately didn’t like the idea of the “found footage” element. The Academy doesn’t like to be told what to do, and doc voters can be pretty fickle. They’re not going to vote for the critical darling like The Perfect Neighbor; they’re gonna go with the political one. They’re not gonna go with the concert doc that made a ton of money; they’ll go with one you have to drive an hour to seek out in theaters. Bottom line: They’re not going to go with the one everyone tells them they should vote for.
Plus, I suspect that doc voters like shorter running times. If you look at the winning titles and nominations over the past years, they usually hover around 90 minutes, rarely going over two hours (the OJ Simpson doc doesn’t count since it was technically a limited series). Hoop Dreams and YCSE both have nearly three-hour running times, which aren’t necessarily branch friendly.
Plus, just because a film is “iconic,” doesn’t mean it resonates. So many unforgettable documentaries that hit the zeitgeist have not been nominated for the Best Documentary Oscar, including Paris is Burning, Grey Gardens, Roger & Me, Blackfish, and even Hoop Dreams director Steve James’ Roger Ebert doc, Life Itself.
What Does This Mean for You Can See Everything?
This isn’t to say that YCSE won’t be nominated in both Best Documentary and Best Picture. It surely would be exciting if it got in in both categories.
But doc voters aren’t the same as other branches, and the best way to get A24’s hit doc into the Oscar race might be to say less and let voters discover it themselves. We need to play evasive like Elizabeth Holmes. We don’t know if we know it’s good.







