It would be a mistake to call Peter Farrelly’s I Play Rocky “high art,” but I bet many will think of it as a great movie. I Play Rocky works on so many parallel levels with the film it takes its “making of” story from that it’s almost dizzying to comprehend. Sylvester Stallone’s story of writing the script for the Best Picture-winning Oscar over three days is already the stuff of legend. Now, fifty years after Rocky’s release, the legend is on film.
Stallone was a struggling actor who was getting laughed out of auditions for his slurred speech and a face that was partially paralyzed due to the delivery doctor severing a nerve when removing him from the womb with a pair of forceps. Despite being on the edge of eviction for years, Stallone never gave up on being a movie star. At his wife Sasha’s (winningly played by AnnaSophia Robb) urging, Stallone wrote a screenplay for himself to play the lead, since no one else was offering. In fact, he wrote more than one.
The first one to grab the notice of producers Irwin Winkler and Robert Chartoff (P.J. Byrne and Toby Kebbell, who are so amusing they could take their act on the road) wasn’t even Rocky. It was a wrestling drama called Paradise Alley, which would eventually get made after Rocky. Winkler and Chartoff recognized a voice in Paradise Alley, but didn’t think it was commercial. Still, they encouraged Stallone to keep going.
One night, Stallone enters a dive bar and sees Muhammad Ali taking on the overmatched Chuck Wepner for Ali’s heavyweight title. Wepner got knocked around the ring for nearly 15 rounds before the referee mercifully stopped the fight. The Bayonne Bleeder (as Wepner was known as) lived up to his name. Ali made a bloody mess of him, but the New Jersey journeyman wouldn’t quit. As Stallone watched Wepner keep coming in the face of all odds, inspiration struck, and over 84 sleepless hours, the screenplay for Rocky was born.
Farrelly’s film is so smart in so many ways. Stallone’s left hand cramps so badly from writing longhand that he has to ice it to keep going. Just like a boxer after a fight. Chartoff and Winkler love the script, but they can’t get Sandy Maddox (a composite studio executive played with gruff hilarity by Tracey Letts) to sign off on the film with Stallone in the lead. Maddox tells Chartoff and Winkler to keep throwing money at Stallone until he caves and they can cast Charles Bronson or Clint Eastwood.
They start at $25,000 and eventually work their way to $360,000 (a fortune in the mid-seventies), but Stallone will not relent. “I play Rocky,” he says in a firm and relentless refrain. Stallone doesn’t have a lot to piss in, or a window to throw it out of. All he has is self-belief. Remarkably, this no-name actor with a soft-core film on his resume won. Not only did he get to star in his movie, but it became the biggest hit of the year, launching Stallone into unlikely superstardom.
It’s an obvious statement to say that the whole movie hinges on the actor playing Stallone. Ippolito hadn’t been seen on screen since 2022, when he landed the role of the man known as “Sly,” but after seeing I Play Rocky, it’s hard to imagine anyone else in the part. Aside from having a remarkable resemblance to Stallone, Ippolito nails the distinct voice, mannerisms, and physicality of the character to such a degree that in re-enactments of scenes from Rocky, you may catch yourself blinking and rubbing your eyes in an effort to be certain that you aren’t looking at the real thing.
Beyond getting Stallone’s voice and movement down, what’s notable about Ippolito is that he somehow doesn’t get caught up in impersonation. Every second Ippolito is on screen, he feels completely authentic and lived-in. He’s not mimicking Stallone; he’s channeling Stallone. He’s so good in the role that I honestly fear casting agents may not be able to separate him from it. He is to Stallone what Christopher Reeve was to Superman: essential and irreplaceable.
The casting in every role is outstanding. Stephan James absolutely nails the bravado and charm of Carl Weathers. Jay Duplass is a riot as Rocky’s director, John G. Avildsen, even if he plays the filmmaker as lovingly insane instead of insane insane, which the real thing was known to be. Matt Dillon is note-perfect as Frank Stallone, Sly’s condescending father. It’s the first high-profile role in some time for Dillon, and he reminds the audience why we loved him in the first place.
Farrelly’s movie mines metric tons of humor from the impasses the production of Rocky faces. Running out of money. Two actors who can’t ice skate (Stallone and Talia Shire) who fall in love on a skating rink. And most significantly, two men playing boxers who have never boxed in their lives. Yet somehow, Rocky —for all its financial limitations, schmaltz, and production headaches —did what every successful film does: it played.
The same thing could be said of I Play Rocky. Hell, it doesn’t just play, it slays. Don’t be surprised if Farrelly’s sweet, corny, uplifting film about making a sweet, corny, uplifting film hijacks the Oscars. Best Film, Best Actor, and Best Screenplay are all in play. Much like the film it’s about, I Play Rocky aims to please the crowd. And boy, does it ever. I know. I was in the crowd. We were pleased. Sure, the ten people in the world who hate Rocky for beating Network, Taxi Driver, and All the President’s Men (and no, it shouldn’t have, but don’t blame Rocky, blame the people who voted for it). People are going to love it. I also have a feeling they are going to vote for it this time, too, and in large numbers.
Don’t forget where you heard it.







