Megan McLachlan takes a look at the 2027 Best Documentary contenders and how Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim factor into the mix.
The last non-war-related documentary to win Best Documentary was Questlove’s Summer of Soul in 2021.
Year after year, the Best Documentary winners at the Oscars have become a space for protest. Navalny profiled Putin’s main instigator, 20 Days in Mariupol gave us a ground-level journalist’s view of the early days of the war in Ukraine, No Other Land showed us the forced displacement of Palestinians, and finally Mr. Nobody Against Putin depicted the Russian dictator’s control of every war narrative, even in primary school.
What We’ve Learned from The Perfect Neighbor: A Cautionary Tale
2027 doesn’t look to be any different, with Poh Si Teng’s American Doctor leading the pack, which follows three doctors trying to treat patients in Gaza. If you thought 20 Days in Mariupol and No Other Land were graphic, you’re not ready for this one, as it doesn’t hold back one bit and for a reason. In the beginning of the film, Si Teng questions whether she should blur images of dead children, and Dr. Mark Perlmutter tells her she must show them because that’s the whole reason why they’re there—to show what’s really going on.
What we’ve learned from last year’s The Perfect Neighbor is that, yes, the Academy doesn’t necessarily love “found footage” documentary films, even if that film was incredibly impressive. Voters are still very much into purposeful storytelling that highlights injustice in the world.
There’s been a lot of brouhaha about Nathan Fielder/Lance Oppenheim’s You Can See Everything, also known as the secret Elizabeth Holmes project that broke Telluride (I did not get to see the film while I was there!). I love Nathan Fielder and while I’m totally psyched for the doc (even though the run time is a little intimidating), I’m not sure Fielder’s brand of humor or style is on par with the Academy’s. After all, if he couldn’t win over the Emmy voters with The Rehearsal (where he learned to fly a damn plane), how is he going to win over one of the more particular branches of voters? I see a lot of prognosticators being so daring as to put it in Best Picture, which may be a better fit (but still a reach), but I don’t see it being a documentary nominee. We shall see though!
2027 Best Documentary Oscar Contenders
American Doctor is undeniably compelling, and there are other documentaries to watch for this upcoming awards season.
An Eye for An Eye – Part true crime/part family drama, Tanaz Eshagian’s film follows one woman coming out of a 14-year prison sentence and her fate being decided by her abusive ex-husband’s family.
A Fox Under a Pink Moon – A portrait of a teenage girl trying to escape Iran for Austria, in which she captures art and her abusive marriage.
Everybody to Kenmure Street – With ICE a hot topic in the United States, this story might resonate with American voters, where a Glasgow community rallies to prevent an immigration raid in their neighborhood.
Everest: The Other Side – Never count out Elizabeth Chai Vasarhelyi and Jimmy Chin. And anything about Mount Everest.
Jane Elliott Against the World – Judd Ehrlich’s film took home Best Documentary at the Bentonville Film Festival over the summer, and the woman at the center of it, still fighting racism in her 90s, is the spitfire educator who gave us the blue-eyed/brown-eyed exercise in schools.
Knife – Alex Gibney has not one, but two documentaries coming out this year. This one covers the 2022 stabbing of Salmon Rushdie and how he recovered from it.
Musk – I would follow director Alex Gibney pretty much anywhere, from Scientology to the mind of Elizabeth Holmes, but spending 4 hours with Elon Musk? Surely, Gibney will pull back the curtain on this polarizing figure, but do we really want to spend this much time with him?
Naza – One of the rumors at Telluride was that the secret screening was this investigative Gaza doc from No Other Land directors Yuval Abraham and Rachel Szor. What a completely different tone that screening would have been! (Yikes.)
Nuisance Bear – Based on their short film, directors Gabriela Osio Vanden and Jack Weisman extend the narrative of Nuisance Bear, a documentary that follows a polar bear looking for purpose in Churchill, Manitoba.
Once Upon a Time in Harlem – This one has buzz, documenting a gathering of some of the most revolutionary Harlem Renaissance artists in 1972.
One in a Million – Jack MacInnes and Itab Azzam’s new film tracks the 10-year journey of a Syrian girl, from Germany and back, and the experiences of her refugee family.
The History of Concrete – Phew. Thank god for a light-hearted film about how concrete is everywhere (and that there’s a difference between it and cement!) from HBO’s other droll comedian (How to with John Wilson was canceled, while The Rehearsal lives).
You Can See Everything – Perhaps this film will make documentaries hip again, the way Michael Moore’s Fahrenheit 911 and Morgan Spurlock’s Super Size Me dominated the early aughts?
My Top 5 Documentary Picks
If I had to list a top five as of right now, I’d rank them like this, based on buzz and having seen three of them.
American Doctor
Jane Elliott Against the World
Naza
Nuisance Bear
Once Upon a Time in Harlem
Each one has a political element to them in some respect. Jane Elliott is especially fiery, someone audiences will love (voters also love documentaries about more obscure individuals, not necessarily the celebrity docs the Emmy voters go for—something to remember). I’ve also heard Once Upon a Time has amazing archival footage.
What am I missing? Let me know in the comments!



![Oscars 2027: Virginie Efira On Being In the Awards Conversation For the ‘Politically Powerful’ ‘All Of A Sudden’ [VIDEO]](https://thecontending.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/SOUDAIN_Photo-12_©CINEFRANCE-STUDIOS-120x86.jpg)



